ADOPTING A CHILD
IN BRITAIN:
by Roger Fenton
This Web page contains the Table of Contents of my book for prospective British adoptive parents. If you are considering adopting a child, click on highlighted headings to read sample sections. The full text is available from Adoption Media. The URL for this book in their online shop is: http://adoptionshop.com/p185/e-books/adopting-a-child-in-britain-e-book-.html.
I: WHAT IS ADOPTION?
What is Parental Responsibility?
II: ARE THERE LOTS OF BABIES TO ADOPT?
Children as a Commodity in a Market Economy
III: MORE ABOUT CHILDREN AVAILABLE FOR ADOPTION
IV: IS ADOPTION RIGHT FOR YOU?
Are You Infertile?
V: ARE YOU RIGHT FOR ADOPTION?
Are You Realistic about the Ups and Downs of Parenthood?
VI: ALTERNATIVES TO ADOPTION
Residence Orders
VII: HAVE YOU GOT WHAT IT TAKES?
Can You Be Honest with Your Child?
VIII: WHO CAN ADOPT?
Your Age and Health
IX: APPLYING TO AN ADOPTION AGENCY
Do You Suffer from Social Worker Phobia?
X: THE APPLICATION PROCESS
Adoption Preparation Classes
XI: GOING TO PANEL
The Panel
XII: WAITING FOR A PLACEMENT
Acceptance is No Guarantee of a Placement
XIII: GETTING TO KNOW YOUR NEW CHILD
Help! We Were Supposed to Be Going on Holiday
XIV: MOVING IN WITH YOU: THE HONEYMOON
You're Not on Your Own: Help is at Hand
XV: THE LAW
The Basic Legal Requirements for Adopters
XVI: AFTER THE ADOPTION ORDER
Telling Others the News
APPENDIX I: OVERSEAS ADOPTION
Why Do You Want to Adopt from Overseas?
APPENDIX II: HOW SOME AGENCIES RESPONDED TO AN INITIAL ENQUIRY FROM A BLACK COUPLE
APPENDIX III: A SHORT HISTORY OF ADOPTION IN THE UK
MORE READING AND RESOURCES
Books
GLOSSARY
SAMPLE SECTIONS
What do these people all have in common?
Yes, they were all either adopted or fostered as children. Just a few of the literally millions of people, some famous, some just your next-door neighbours, who didn’t grow up in the families they were born into.
There is hardly anyone in the country who hasn’t been touched by adoption in one way or another: if not one of the 10% directly affected, as an adoptee, adopter or birth parent, birth or adoptive sibling, or as the partner or child of an adoptee, then as classmate, friend or work mate. In my own family and circle of acquaintances I can count over 30 adoptees, not including my own children or the ones I know purely through my work as an adoption counsellor.
There is probably no culture in the world or period of history where adoption is unknown. In parts of the Pacific Islands adoption is routine, and according to the anthropologist Margaret Mead, among the Manus people of what is now Papua New Guinea, before World War II, fully 25% of all the children were adoptees. In the mid-17th century in what is now the northeast of the United States, some villages of the Iroquois League were estimated to consist of 2/3 or more adoptees, following the introduction of European diseases, with 50% death rates in the ensuing plagues, and the practice of capturing members of other tribes to adopt in place of the deceased. In our culture adoption is common and an open subject, not something secret or shameful. But in some other countries the stigma is still so powerful that adoption outside the extended family is very rare or never admitted in public.
You are reading this book because you’re interested in adopting a child. Good! That’s what I want to help you to do. I wouldn’t be writing it if I didn’t think adoption were not just worthwhile, but one of the world’s greatest inventions! But before we talk about the HOW of adoption, we need to really understand the WHAT and even more important, the WHY. Adoption is not something casual. Adoption is, even more than raising your own biological children, an adventure. And like any adventure you need to read the guidebooks and prepare carefully beforehand. There are some badly marked crossroads, there are dangerous rapids in the river and hidden reefs waiting to shipwreck the unwary. But when you reach the end of the journey there is a feeling of accomplishment and satisfaction (maybe relief, too, at having got there in one piece), which in some ways makes the view from the mountaintop even more beautiful than if you had travelled the more conventional route. This book aims to help signpost the way and chart the waters, to give you some idea of the rewards of adoption and its pitfalls.
However, I also expect to put some of you off adoption altogether. Adoption is not for everyone, and if you find after reading this book that it isn’t for you, then you may have saved yourself and a child years of unhappiness. It is not easy to imagine anything worse, or more disastrous to all concerned, than a failed adoption. That’s why I ask you to do some hard, honest thinking early on. This is not just for you but also for the sake of the child you may adopt. Some others of you may find that while adoption is not the right way for you to bring children into your lives, there are other ways to do this which suit you better.
There’s no point pretending to you that adoption is a stress-free process for those involved. It usually isn’t, even for those adopting for the nth time, who’ve been through it all before. It’s invariably hard for everyone, most especially for the child being adopted, even if he or she is too young to understand what’s going on. Most of the stress is caused by the necessity to be sure that the adoption is going to succeed, which entails a lot of questions, form filling, evening classes, reading and introspection. But some of the stress is caused by human stupidity, spite or sheer bloody-mindedness, or by that most intractable and convenient of scapegoats: bureaucracy. Some adopted children grow into their new families virtually without trouble; others will try to destroy their new families, and some will succeed. Most birth parents are the victims of overwhelming circumstances which few of us would be able to overcome; some are simply unable to cope with life at all; a very few seemingly make a good case for bringing back hanging. Some adoptions proceed through the courts without a hitch; some take years, cost a small fortune in legal fees and wind up in the House of Lords, due to the incompetence of lawyers or the social services, vindictiveness by birth parents or just Sod’s Law working overtime.
There are other books about how to adopt, by social workers. There are also books by adoptive parents about how their families came about and grew. And there are many biographies and autobiographies of famous and not-so-famous adoptees.
This book is different: it is a book about how to adopt, written by an experienced adopter, from the adopter’s point of view, telling it like it really is, warts and all. I have no vested interest in adoption (except as a very satisfied consumer). I can safely air some of those fears and feelings all prospective adopters have but are afraid to talk about in case they scupper their chances. There is no pretence here that all adoption agencies are as good as each other, or that all social workers are caring and professionally competent, because it just ain’t so. Some social workers are marvellous; some are awful. Some agencies are efficient and well managed; some are grossly incompetent and should be shut down. But in general, adoption in the UK is remarkably well run and trouble free for prospective adopters, although our care system for children does leave a great deal to be desired, and the services available for families who have adopted and need help are also very undeveloped. Our two great boasts in this country are:
Together these go a long way towards ensuring that the right people get to adopt and for the right reasons, and that everyone who should benefit does so. But there is nevertheless a lot of room for improvement:
I don’t aim to cover the special aspects of raising adopted children in any depth. Even children adopted as tiny healthy babies need special parenting in some respects; children adopted at older ages often need very special parenting indeed. That is a special field, with its own experts and books, and the needs are so different for different kinds of children that it is best to get specialist advice if and when you need it. I do however try to indicate in a general way some of the problems modern adoption can pose for parents, to help you make informed decisions and know what to look out for along the way.
The laws governing adoption are not uniform throughout the United Kingdom. This book is aimed in its legal and procedural sections at readers in England and Wales. If you live elsewhere things will be somewhat different, although the underlying principles are identical.
Throughout the book I give examples in boxes from real-life families. A few of these are from my own family; most are not. But they are all told in the first person.
There is only one legitimate purpose for adoption: to find a new and permanent family (the rather twee term “forever family” is often used) for a child who, for whatever reason, can no longer be cared for by his family of birth or his current legal parents.
Historically, even within living memory, adoption was often recommended as a way to patch up a failing marriage or as a cure for an adult’s loneliness. It was a way to bring the joy of children to a childless couple. It was a means of gaining more working hands for a farm or family business or help in the kitchen for a family with too many children of one sex and too few of the other. It provided someone to care for aged and sick relatives. It relieved the financial burden of too many children in the days before reliable contraception. It was a way for a “fallen woman” to escape the wrath of a scandalised society and for her illegitimate child to conceal her shameful origins. It was a means of cementing alliances between families and clans. In all these situations the interests of the child were considered last if at all. Those days have long gone.
One of the hardest lessons for some prospective adopters to learn is that adoption now is about finding the right home for a child. The interests of the child come first and last; the interests of the adopters are emphatically secondary.
That said, there is no doubt that a good adoption fills the needs of many people. A child who can no longer be cared for in his birth family finds a permanent, happy home. A family who want a child get one. Birth parents who cannot cope are given a chance to start again (although they are not relieved of the loss, pain and guilt they almost always feel). The social workers are relieved of a part of their caseload. And society gives a chance of a better, more constructive life to a child who might otherwise grow up to become a drain on the social services, courts and prisons. A classic win-win situation.
But in considering these positive side-effects we must never lose sight of the child’s interests. If we as prospective adopters are not able to put the child’s interests first we have no business adopting. We may not always agree with the decisions of social workers, but with rare exceptions they are trying their hardest in a difficult situation to do what is best for the child; they are able to look at the picture as a whole, disinterestedly; and they have a lot more information about the needs of that child than we, the prospective adopters do; so they are in the best position to make those decisions. It may be hard for us to accept rejection or a decision not to go ahead with a planned placement, but we must accept their decisions, unless we have clear reasons for suspecting that people have really made a bad decision from the child’s point of view or seriously think we have been unjustly treated.
The term “older children” includes not only young school children; children as old as 17 can be adopted, and there are plenty of teenagers needing new families. Not all older children have severe problems, although there is a definite statistical correlation between age at placement and the severity of the child’s problems, as well as the likelihood that the adoption will break down.
Many people find babies scary (do they break easily? how do I know when it’s hungry? why won’t it stop crying? what’s that rash on its head?, why does it sleep so much?), and would feel happier and more confident with an older child. If you have already raised one family, you will have extra skills and could find the challenges of an older child exciting and especially fulfilling. If you are over the age of 35 you have no choice but to consider an older child; you are extremely unlikely to be considered for a baby, unless it has other special needs.
It used to be considered that any child over a year old was unadoptable. No more. Healthy white children under five are now considered to present no problems in terms of finding new families. The situation is slightly different for black children. Because of economic discrimination both partners in black families usually have to work to make ends meet, so that school-aged black children find homes more easily than toddlers.
The last few years have revealed that while the problem is more common in older children, even very young children can suffer lasting psychological trauma from the repeated transfer from one carer to another or due to maternal deprivation, even if they never had contact with their birth mothers. The condition is often obvious to the new adopters within days of placement, and just as often ignored or denied by social workers, most of whom have never heard of it. It is called RAD (reactive attachment disorder) or just attachment disorder, and it makes it virtually impossible for a child to bond to his or her new parents. Children who have been passed around foster families, abused children from dysfunctional birth families, and children from poorly-run children’s homes are most at risk. In a desperate attempt to control their lives they refuse to allow any adult to control them. They specialise in a seemingly perverse ability to appear perfectly normal to professionals and other people outside their families while determinedly attempting to destroy them. These children are truly victims of the System. There is more later in this book about attachment disorder.
Serious attachment disorder is not, however common. Most older children do make the transition from one home to another, although they need careful and sometimes long preparation, and it is by no means easy for them or their new parents. Many older children have justifiably become suspicious of all adults because of the way they have controlled or abused them, and it can take a long time to overcome this.
|
If they have bad memories of previous families they may make heroic efforts to blend in. They may have fears associated with neglect and abuse and need long-term psychological or psychiatric help to get over these. A fear of rejection can make them “too good,” unable to give vent to normal anger, frustration or disagreement, in case it brings another rejection. They may need to be constantly reassured that this is the end of the line, that they will never be sent back, no matter what happens. They may have fears that they will be kidnapped back by their birth families; conversely, they may believe that their new family has kidnapped them from a family which they have idealised, and be deeply resentful of their new situation.
Regression is common with older children. They may have missed out on a proper babyhood or childhood in a chaotic household or because they had to look after younger children or incompetent parents. They may want somehow to experience being your baby, in order to feel more completely yours. No matter. If they feel the need, it has to be gone through. However strange it may be having a seven-year-old with a baby bottle or dummy or even in nappies, it’s only temporary. It is very common for them to regress only in part of their behaviour. You may have a child for a while who is a baby, a toddler and a junior-school pupil all at once, changing from one to the other with bewildering speed. It is simply a more extreme case of what most children go through when Mum has another baby. And if it’s confusing for you, think of how it must be for him! Relax and let him get through it at his own pace; any anxiety on your part will just make matters more difficult. Anyway, it will be good practice for later, because the same sort of thing happens to most children when they are teenagers: seven one minute, fifteen going on 23 the next.
|
Time is a great healer, and we all tend to forget unpleasant past experiences. A child removed from an inadequate family may come to forget the problems and remember only the good times - never-ending television, living on take-away burgers and pop, bedtime when he felt like it, no homework - it is only natural that he will not understand the reasons why he is now in a different family. The new family has to help him come to a realistic understanding of his past, without however running the birth family down. Barring serious abuse in the birth family, older children are very likely to want and need to keep in touch with their birth parents or siblings or grandparents, even if their previous life was not happy.
If a child is able to understand what adoption is, the social services and courts have a legal obligation to explain what is happening and to get his consent. An older child may decide against adoption in order not to sever his legal relationship with the birth family completely, but still want to have a new permanent family via long-term fostering. Or it may take several years for an older child to decide that this is the right family and that he wants to be adopted.
Older children’s personalities, likes and dislikes are already largely settled. It is even more important than usual for older children to have continuity of care in terms of religion and ethnicity, to keep the extent of disruption to their lives to a minimum, but even transracial placements of older children do take place and can be successful. They may find the change in lifestyle, school, food, geography or dialect hard to make. In other cases it may be that a complete and dramatic contrast between the new life and a painful past will be therapeutic for older children, but not very often. No matter how bad the past may have been they still need continuity and stability.
They may at first be subject to night fears, bedwetting and tantrums, caused by the fears and strain which inevitably accompany the upheavals which their lives have seen. They may find comfort in routine, but on the other hand, if they had a chaotic start to life they may have no concept of things like regular meals and bedtimes (although an older child will very likely have spent significant time in a therapeutic or pre-adoption foster family or children’s home where intensive work will have been done on matters like these). In contrast to babies, adoption of older children involves real and conscious compromise and negotiation between you and the child.
Adoption can sometimes turn an older child’s problems around literally overnight.
|
Older children, unless they are very developmentally delayed, disabled, or temporarily regressing, don’t need to have their nappies changed. They can feed and dress themselves. They go to school, instead of being constantly underfoot. They can hold a conversation. They can walk unaided. They don’t stick hair grips into the electrical outlets. They don’t run out into the street in front of articulated lorries. They don’t have to have prams or special car seats or other expensive baby equipment. They don’t have 3:00 a.m. feeds. They can run errands. They can play games properly. Older disabled children, even the few who need a great deal of practical care, can with few exceptions make their needs known and many are very independent and a joy to parent. Older children are great fun. Enjoy!
This is not an easy thing to define. It's rather like good art: you know it when you see it.
When it comes down to it, I think this is possibly the most important criterion, and paradoxically, it comes very close to a total no-no. Adoption is basically a selfish thing to do. We adopt because we need to adopt. Many of the bad reasons to adopt listed in the previous section are also selfish, but they are selfish in a definite, definable way:
Each of these reasons would use the adopted child for a specific purpose and they all focus on one particular aspect or quality of the child, not the child as a whole or for its own sake. They are all essentially exploitative. But the best motive for adoption, while it uses children to fill a need in ourselves, uses them in the way they are intended to be used. Nature gives people, men and women, broody feelings for a purpose: so we will go out and reproduce the species.
That’s what I mean by a “child-shaped hole in your life.” If you get broody when a friend has a baby; if you get a sinking feeling in the pit of your stomach when you see a father with his little boy; if you go to school Christmas pageants and cry because your child is not the ninth shepherd; if you sometimes cross the street to avoid passing a toy shop; if you involve yourself with other people’s children to help assuage these feelings but are only partially satisfied; if you want a child for herself, for her own sake - these are all indications of a child-shaped hole in your life which will only be filled by a child of your own. Go for it!
You don’t have to be married, you don’t have to be childless, you don’t have to be heterosexual, to have these feelings. You can still adopt.
But beware if any of these feelings get out of hand. If you are seriously tempted to steal a child; if you think about pretending you are pregnant or pretending you have children; if you think about ways to entice a child away from his parents; if you find yourself having sexual feelings towards children - these are very serious signs that you must not adopt, because they are not natural, and you would not be able to have a natural relationship with a child. You need counselling from a skilled professional.
There are some extra complications in raising adopted children.
When you’re staggering groggily up the stairs at three in the morning with a bottle in your hand; when your child comes home from school with a grubby drawing of an elephant; when he comes home unrecognisable underneath a layer of football pitch mud; when she goes up the aisle for her first Holy Communion; when he brings home his GCSE results (no matter what they are); when you hold your first grandchild for the first time - spare a thought for some woman and man out there who would have given anything to be able to be there.
Raising someone else’s child is not the same as raising one born to you. In addition to being your own child’s parents you are acting in trust for the birth parents and society at large. Your child is both yours and theirs, and while you have all the good times and bad times over the years, much of what your child has that brings you joy and tears comes from her birth parents. Be thankful for that and be worthy of their trust. Being allowed to adopt is one of the greatest privileges in the world.
WHAT POSITIVE QUALITIES ARE AGENCIES LOOKING FOR IN ADOPTERS?
One of our collection of “telling” stories for small children describes an assessment interview of 30 years ago, when the social worker asked the prospective adopters what they had to offer one of her “special babies.” They answered that they had a house, a nursery all decorated, a dog and a cat. Each time she answered that it wasn’t enough, and did they have anything more. Finally the parents answered that they had lots of love, and that was all the nice social worker lady needed to hear. Unfortunately that won’t do now, if it ever did. Adopters need love, to be sure, but like having a dog and a cat, it isn’t enough for today’s children.
The sections above covered some of the areas that social workers consider when assessing people to adopt. They are the more tangible factors. Even more important are the intangible factors that go to make up a family which can accept a child into their home and lives and help that child overcome her past problems and make a start to a new life. Some of these are touched on in other places in this and other chapters, but I want to mention them all together here as well. They are mostly taken (modified) from guidelines sent to prospective applicants by Parents for Children, a voluntary agency in London, which places very special children and offers a high-quality aftercare service , and also from the book Adopting a Child. This is a far cry from the advice you might have received 30 or 40 years ago.
If you can satisfy the agency that you can provide what a child needs in these areas, almost everything else is negotiable.
It’s very difficult to give a precise answer to this question, because so much depends on the circumstances of each individual adoption, and especially on the child. There are certain things which need to be done, or phases which need to be gone through, but not necessarily in the same order for each placement.
|
|
|
If you are adopting a sibling group, everything becomes more complicated, of course. They may not all be in the same foster home, involving more social workers and foster carers. It is possible to stagger introductions with a larger sibling group, so that the placements don’t all happen together, but rather, say, one a month, giving everyone a little time to settle down before the next arrival. With most sibling groups the children act as mutual supports, making things easier for each other and you.
Almost always the foster family is very supportive and helpful during this period. They usually know the child better than anyone else and want the best for her. Sometimes they have legitimate reasons for thinking that the match is not going to work, and will discuss it with the social workers. But very occasionally a foster family will simply take an irrational dislike to prospective adopters and deliberately try to scupper the arrangements, like a father who thinks no boy is good enough to marry his little girl. If you think this is happening, tell your social worker. It’s possible that it has happened before with other prospective adopters and this foster family. There will be something which can be done to overcome the problem.
At some point everyone will decide “it’s time,” and you will take the child home for good. The next stage is usually known as the honeymoon period, and I discuss it in the next chapter. You pack the child’s bags in the car, and off you go.
It is probably not the end of the child’s relationship with the foster family. That will probably tail off naturally over the next few years, but there is certainly no reason to terminate it artificially or completely. Almost all foster parents are interested in how their former charges are getting along in the world. You will continue to need their knowledge and advice in the months ahead, as you discover gaps in your information base, and you will be phoning them up to find out whether little Winston really is allergic to every cereal except Frosties, or whether he’s just trying it on. The foster family may well be the best source of some kinds of information for the child when she grows up: a foster carer who originally took a child as part of a plan to rehabilitate her with her birth family and had significant contact with them before it turned into a pre-adoption placement, will know a lot which could be useful to your child later as she needs to know more about herself.
|
Simply because it is usually beneficial to everyone concerned.
A study carried out for the government estimated conservatively that fully a third of all adoptees either have received or will receive their original birth certificate information - and that only applies to those adopted before the age of 10 and adopted outside their extended families. No one knows the full figures for sure, because, especially since the 1970s there have been both official and unofficial channels for that information. No one knows how many of those people will go on to trace their birth families, either. What is known is that the reaction to the opening up of access to birth record in England and Wales (Scotland has always had open access) in 1976 opened the floodgates to many more applications for those records than had been anticipated, and that women request their birth certificates in substantially greater numbers than men do.
Tracing is the process of using whatever information is available, often only the original birth certificate and the agency’s contemporary records as a starting point, to find out where someone in the birth family is now. Adoptees who trace generally look for the mother first, both because her name is often the only one on the birth certificate, but also because mothers have a special significance for them. Tracing can extend beyond the birth parents, especially if they have died, disappeared or are unavailable for contact, to include other members of the birth family. Where there has been continuing contact between the families during childhood, tracing in adulthood is either unnecessary or much easier.
Tracing the birth family can be done independently, using the information supplied by the birth certificate and any additional information available. It can be done using the services of a private investigator or organisation which specialises in this is the most prominent), by advertising in the press or on the Internet, or by using one of several contact registers set up for that purpose.
Tracing is overwhelmingly done by an adult adoptee, but it can be done by the adoptive parents while the adoptee is still under age, or, rarely, by the birth family. Successful tracing (and not all attempts result in a relative being found) usually results in contact with someone in the birth family, but not necessarily: the birth family may refuse contact, or the adoptee may be satisfied with simply knowing where they are and that they are well, without going on to make contact. Tracing can take place at any age; even middle-aged adoptees trace and may be reunited with aged relatives.
RETURN to the
Top of this page
GO TO THE:
Famous Adoptees, Foster Children and Others (Biographical Directory) Homepage
This page is maintained by Roger R. Fenton:
"Cul-Ffordd"
2 Rhes Sant George
Llangawsai
Aberystwyth
Ceredigion SY23 1HE
Wales
United Kingdom
Copyright (c) 2000 by Roger Fenton. All rights reserved.
Permission is granted to reproduce profiles or quote from these pages for non-commercial or educational purposes, provided full acknowledgment is given.
Last updated: 21 January 2005